Tampilkan postingan dengan label Critical Theory. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label Critical Theory. Tampilkan semua postingan

Rabu, 07 Januari 2015

Desire From Given Identity and Punishment To Forming Children’s Identity In Roald Dahl’s “Charlie and the Chocolate Factory” (2)



Literary works have various genres such as drama, myth, romance, irony, comedy, tragedy, lyric, poetry, epic poetry, prose, etc. Besides, there is one interesting genre because it's often applied both to children and adolescent literature. In fact, not all genres are suitable to be applied to several literary works for certain age categories. There are times when a genre would be very appropriate to be applied in adult literary works, but it may be problematic if the writer applied that to children's literature. There is also a genre that is suitable to be applied to literary works in General (both children and adolescent literature) such as the fantastic.

A literary work can be described as "fantastic literature" if the story about normal world if it combine the normal human world (the real world) and supernatural stuffs (events and/or things) that does not make sense. According to Louis Vax:
“The fantastic narrative generally describes men like ourselves, inhabiting the real world, suddenly confronted by inexplicable.” (in “The Fantastic”, p. 26)
and H. P. Lovecraft:
“…A tale is fantastic if the reader experiences an emotion of profound fear and terror, the presence of unsuspected worlds and powers.”
(in “The Fantastic”, p. 34-35)

Referring to the quote above, Roald Dahl’s "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory" can also be categorized as a work of the fantasy genre.

            "Charlie and The Chocolate Factory" tell the story of five children (Charlie Bucket, Augustus Gloop, Violet Beauregarde, Veruca Salt and Mike Teavee) who gets 'Golden Ticket' to visit a mysterious factory owned by Willy Wonka. When the factory was still operating, it was the most delicious chocolate manufacturer with many employees came out and entered the factory to work. In recent years, has never seen the activity of the workers in the factory, there was no lights on behind its windows and the fence was tightly closed. People rumored that the factory was stopped operating because the owners were disappointed to workers who was resigned then opened their own factory after studying the various recipes and techniques for making candy and the most delicious chocolate from the factory.

Charlie, a child who comes from (an arguably) poor family always passes the factory while before and after his school-time. He never saw any signs of life or any activity there - the fence is always closed, with no one there- Until one day when Charlie passes through the factory, he saw the lights that lit up the factory again and silhouettes of people who work from a distance. He was instantly covered with joyful thoughts because as everyone knows, the products made by Wonka's chocolate factory are always the most delicious and has the most excellent quality.
           
            Even though it seems there is no activity in the factory, but Charlie's curiosity towards the factory was not over yet. He would like to know how can, there are so many activities in the factory, but he has never seen anyone passing through in the area of Wonka's chocolate factory until Willy Wonka holding a contest with prizes for free chocolate products that are not limited and an invitation to a visit the factory for a day for five people who can find a ‘Golden Ticket’ in every product manufactured by Wonka's Chocolate Factory.
             
             This is where the adventure of five children (Charlie Bucket, Augustus Gloop, Violet Beauregarde, Veruca Salt, and Mike Teavee) in the factory owned by Willy Wonka finally begins. Thoughts on the factory with a variety of mechanical equipment, advanced machinery, and people with sterile clothing disappeared when they entered the factory. There is no such employees like what we have usually seen in common factories; in this factory, the employees are not looking like humans in general, but the Oompa-Loompas which are derived from Loompaland. In this factory, those children were treated by a variety of scenery and a very unusual situation; a boat made of sweets, chocolate rivers, in lieu of a mixer the factory using a waterfall, squirrels, and various magical products manufactured by Wonka's factory.

Unlike a usual field trip, in this factory, children are not allowed to touch anything, should not ask any questions about the factory, they visited (when they ask such a question, Willy Wonka would not be happy and the question will not be answered correctly). Surprisingly, despite a series of accidents that befall Augustus, Veruca, Violet, and Mike in this factory, Willy Wonka -the owner of the factory- as the person in charge at the ‘field trip’ is thus being relaxed and tend to be less concerned with the plight of those children's. Willy Wonka only shows attention to Charlie and his grandfather even at the end of the story, Willy Wonka decides to give his magical chocolate factory to Charlie.

            After reading her story, I was actually more interested in discussing the desire that appears on the attitude of the children who had an accident at the factory and the unique but terrible punishments in returns. Before discussing the desire that becomes a problem for these children, it might be worthwhile to first acknowledge that according to Epicurus (in "Dahl and Philosophy") "desire" is divided into 3 types:
1.         Natural and necessary desires
Desires that you must satisfy to keep your body and mind in a healthy state.
2.         Natural but not necessary desires
Desires that you may wanted as “variation” in your experiences.
3.         The unnatural, unnecessary desires
Desires which are a chief source of human misery –we became convinced that we need things that, in fact aren’t necessary.
(in Roald Dahl and Philosophy, p. 10-12)
        
           Desire owned by Augustus, Veruca, Violet, and Mike can be categorized as "The unnatural, unnecessary desires" because eating is the only activity that attracts Augustus Gloop’s attention who gets the first 'Golden Ticket' 
            “ ‘Eating is his hobby, you know. That’s all he’s interested in.’ ” (p.34)
Veruca Salt who is eager to get a 'Golden Ticket' perform various actions that were already beyond the limits of reasonableness, like shows her anger to her parents, and keep whining or screaming, and some kicking act if she is not getting a ticket yet
“ ‘My little Veruca got more and more upset each day, and every time I went home she would scream at me. “Where’s my Golden Ticket! I want my Golden Ticket!” And she would lie for hours on the floor, kicking and yelling in the most disturbing way.” (p. 36)
Next is Violet Beauregarde who have an excessive fondness for chewing gum as if she was not interested in anything except for chewing gum
“ ‘I just adore gum. I can’t do without it. I munch it all day long except for a few minutes at mealtimes when I take it out and stick it behind my ear for safekeeping. To tell you the truth, I simply wouldn’t feel comfortable if I didn’t have that little wedge of gum to chew on every moment of the day, I really wouldn’t.’ “  (p. 42)
Mike Teavee is the last one. Somewhat different from the previous three children who get the Golden Ticket as related to his hobby (Augustus) and deliberately seek to be able to get the ticket (Veruca and Violet), Mike does not seem too concerned with the Golden Ticket that he got successfully, but just as Augustus, Veruca and Violet, Mike also showed an excessive attitude over his obsession with television He'll be very angry if anyone bothers or blocking hos focus while he watching television, as if his eyes are glued on the television screen
“ ’The Teavee household, […] was crammed, like all others,with excited visitors when our reporter arrived, but young Mike Teavee, the lucky winner, seemed extremely annoyed by the whole business. “Can’t you fools see I’m watching television?” he said angrily, “I wish you wouldn’t interrupt!” " (p. 44)

Are there no other activities that can be done by Augustus, who consider eating as a hobby and the only activity that can make him interested? Should Veruca crying constantly just like almost yelling and kicking with raging despite her father had tried to find a Golden Ticket for her? Is it reasonable for Violet to chew the gum all time and mean to other people by sticking her chewing gum on the elevator button? Whether Mike reaction when there are people who disturb his focus when watching television and shouting to he reporter who (supposedly) much older than a nine-year-old boy could be considered as a reasonable act?
  
Obsession and excessive attitude shown by those children over something they like and they want to seem already beyond reasonable limits (which is called “unnatural desires”) and “unnecessary desires” because if Augustus Gloop reduce or limit the appetite, if Veruca not get a Golden Ticket, if Violet did not manage to break the record for gum chewing, and if Mike can't watch television, though it really isn't a problem. They will not get hurt or die. Because eating with monstrous portion, chew gum, get a Golden Ticket, and watching television only serves as a "variation” in their lives.

As is often said by the sages that everything which is exaggerated for sure will bring bad effects. Likewise with these children who eventually had to accept the 'punishment' for not being able to control their desires in order to remain within normal limits / reasonable.
In the chapter "Augustus Gloop Goes Up the Pipe", Augustus had been warned not to approach the chocolate river, but he ignores the shouts that warned him to stay away from the river. Augustus, who thought his hobby is eating and food are the only thing that can attract his attention was not concerned with his situation
“But Augustus was deaf to everything except the call of his enormous stomach. He was now lying full length on the ground with his head far out over the river, lapping up the chocolate like a dog.” (p. 81)
He wasn't even paying attention to his own position for being too preoccupied with chocolate flowing in the river in front of him and eventually he fell into the river
“For suddenly there was a shriek, and then a splash, and into the river went Augustus Gloop, and in one second he had disappeared under the brown surface.” (p. 82)

Violet Beauregarde who cannot control herself when entering the room where the giant machine to make the little strip of Wonka's magic chewing-gum that can replace breakfast, lunch, and supper. As mentioned previously, violet has the great interest and ambition to the gum. Although in the chapter “Good-bye Violet” Wonka already explained that the product has not been perfected, she does not care and still chewing it.
“ ‘…just so long as it’s a piece of gum and I can chew it, then that’s for me! And quickly she took her own world-record piece of chewing-gum out of her mouth and stuck it behind her left ear. ‘Come on Mr Wonka,’ She said, ‘hand over this magic gum of yours and we’ll see if the thing works.” (p. 105)
As a result, Violet’s body began to swell and change its color to purple like a giant blueberry when chewing gum has entered the 'dessert stage'
“Her body was swelling up and changing shape at such a rate that within a minute it had turned into nothing less than an enormous round blue ball –a gigantic blueberry, in fact- and all that remained of Violet Beauregarde herself was a tiny pair of legs and a tiny pair of arms sticking out of the great round fruit and little head on top.” (p. 107)
Veruca Salt, the girls who come from families that could be considered rich and her parents able to buy anything for Veruca by using his wealth. He always wants anything which belongs to others, such as when she wanted a Golden Ticket after Augustus Gloop became the first person to get it. Because her parents always buy whatever she wished and desired by Veruca, she grew into a selfish girl who always ask for various things she saw.
In the chapter “The Oompa-Loompas” Veruca begs her father to get her an Oompa-Loompa,
“Daddy! I want an Oompa-Loompa! I want you to get me an Oompa-Loompa! I want an Oompa-Loompa right away! I want to take it home with me! Go on. Daddy! Get me an Oompa-Loompa!” (p. 80)
In the chapter "Down The Chocolate River", this girl asked her father to buy her the same items as which belong to Willy Wonka,
“Daddy! […] I want a boat like this! I want you to go buy me a big pink boiled-sweet boat exactly like Mr. Wonka’s! And I want lots of Oompa-Loompas to row me about, and I want a chocolate river and I want…I want…” (p. 91)
Chapter "Veruca in The Nut Room" is Veruca’s climax. This time, Veruca wants a squirrel after seeing trained squirrels which worked for Willy Wonka,
            “Hey, Mummy! […] I’ve decided that I want a squirrel! Get me one of those squirrels!” (p. 120)
“I don’t care about that! […] I want one. All I’ve got at home is two dogs, four cats, and six bunny rabbits and two parakeets, and three canaries, and a green parrot, and a turtle and a bowl of goldfish and a cage of white mice and a silly old hamster! I want a squirrel!” (p. 120)

Her desire has been unable to be stopped until she gets recklessly into a special room where the squirrels are working to take a squirrel that she wanted. Unfortunately, the squirrels which saw her once rushed to Veruca’s body
“She reached out her hands to grab the squirrel…but as she did so…in that first split second when her hands started to go forward, there was a sudden flash of movement in the room, like a flash of brown lightning  and every single squirrel around the table took a flying leap towards her and landed on her body.
Twenty-five of them caught hold of her right arm, and pinned it down.
Twenty-five more caught hold of her left arm, and pinned that down.
Twenty-five caught hold of her right leg and anchored it to the ground.
Twenty-four caught hold of her left leg.
And the one remaining squirrel (obviously the leader of them all) climbed up on to her shoulder and started tap-tap-tapping the wretched girl’s head with its knuckles.” (p, 121)
and treat it as if she was a nut that must be sorted 
            “The squirrel on her shoulder went tap-tap-tapping the side of her head with his knuckles.
Then all at once, the squirrels pulled Veruca to the ground and started carrying her across the floor.” (p. 122)

The last, Mike Teavee who became very excited when he sees a chocolate that can be taken from the television screen because he was obsessed with television. In the chapter "Mike Teavee is Sent by Television", he could no longer withstand the excessive desire for trying to insert himself into the magical television as Charlie takes the chocolate from that television although Wonka had warned him not to do so.
“But Mike Teavee was already off and running. The moment he heard Mr Wonka saying, ‘I’m pretty sure it could…of course it could,’ he turned away and started running as fast as he could towards the other end of the room where the great camera was standing. ‘Look at me!’ he shouted as he ran. ‘I’m going to be the first person in the world to be sent by television!’ “(p. 139 - 140)
As his punishment, Mike Teavee managed to get out of the television with a much different form. The size of Mike’s body has been turned into a very mini because as explained by Mr. Wonka in the chapter “The Television-Chocolate Room”,
“ ‘It has to be big, […] because wehenever you send something by television, it always comes out much smaller than it was when it went in. Even with ordinary television, when you photograph a big man, he never comes out on your screen any taller than a pencil, does he?...’ ” (p. 137)

Those punishments that received by the children can be regarded as a just retribution because they (gluttonous Augustus; Violet, who is lack of manners; Mike, who is lack of self-control, and spoiled Veruca Salt) have failed to live up to a moral ideal. But when referring to Heidegger in the following Dahl and Philosophy,
 “Martin Heidegger (1889-1976) […] suggests that most people are essentially shaped by the world around them. They don’t spend very much critically reflecting on who they are and what they want to be. […], they exist in the world as a projection of their history and environment-“ (in “Dahl and Philosophy”, p. 109)
and if we look back at the reactions of the parents when their children are in an unpleasant position in this novel, then the punishment/reward received by the children as well as their failure to live up to the ideal of a moral truth cannot be separated from parental influence.
             
            In the case of Augustus Gloop, from the beginning of his appearance, his mother has already indicated that she was pleased and proud with Augustus who consider eating is his hobby.
“Eating is his hobby, you know. That’s all he’s interestd in. But still, that’s better than being a hooligan and shooting off zip guns and things like that in his spare time, isn’t it? And what I always say is, he wouldn’t go on eating like he does unless he needed nourishment, would he? It’s all vitamins, anyway.” (p, 34)

Veruca Salt has also become a selfish, temperamental, and less (or even no) respect others because his parents always undertakes all Veruca’s requests because they are accustomed to using money/wealth to fulfill any of her desire because it’s the only way that will stop Veruca from raging. When Veruca was interviewed about how could she got a Golden Ticket, Mr. Salt sets forth how he bought the Wonka bars in great numbers with reason:
“Well, I just hated to see my little girl feeling unhappy like that so I vowed I would keep up the search until I’d got her what she wanted.” (p. 37)

If only because he does not want to see his daughter crying because she wanted a Golden Ticket badly, whether or not there are other ways that are more reasonable and sensible? The notion that Veruca’s parents rely on their wealth for her daughter's happiness is not only seen from how often Veruca asks for things that are not for sale. As living beings can also be purchased if you have abundant wealth
“ ‘Very well, Wonka,’ he said importantly, taking out a wallet full of money, ‘how much d’you want for one of these squirrels? Name your price.’ “ (p. 120)

On Violet, things happened seems more confusing; When she asks Willy Wonka for the magic gum forcibly, her mother rebuked his behavior is considered shameful
“ ‘don’t let’s do anything silly, Violet.’ ” (p. 105)
But, when Violet had started chewing gum and explain a various textures, aromas, and the delicacy of a variety of dishes contained in a thin piece of magical chewing gum, her mother actually looks very supportive of what is being done by her daughter,
“ ‘Keep chewing, baby!’ said Mr Beauregarde. ‘Keep right on chewing! This is a great day for the Beauregardes! Our little girl is the first person in the world to have a chewing-gum meal!’ ” (p. 106)

Instead, Mike Teavee’s parents did not prevent their son to step closer to the Television-Chocolate at all, this could be the description of the attitude of those who are not too concerned with what others have done including not paying much attention to Mike's inability in controlling himself against his interest in television. But when Mike had to be punished (turned into a human-sized mini), Mr. Teavee take decisive action with plans to keep Mike out from television.
“ ‘… I’m throwing all television set right out the window the moment we get home. I’ve had enough of television!’ ” (p. 143)
In this section there is a suspicion that the reaction shown by Mike when there are people (journalists) who accidentally blocking his view towards the television when interviewing the children who get the Golden Ticket, as well as a habit to equip himself with various toy weapons could be the influence of his father who seemed to be very firm.
             
             The influence of parents or the environment also expressed by Heidegger in his writings about "Dasein" or in English means “existence”:
“In talking, Dasein Expresses itself [spricht sich … aus] not because it has, in the first instance, been encapsulated as something ‘internal’ over against something outside, but because as Being-in-the-world it is already ‘outside’ when it understands” (in “Being and Time”, p. 205)

Consciously or unconsciously, parents actually play a major role to built the good or the bad of their children's personality, according to Sartre:
“Human reality is not something which exists first in order afterwards to lack this or that; it exists first as lack and in immediate, synthetic connection with what it lacks” (in “Being and Nothingness”, p. 89)
It's true, the identity of the parents can be temporarily attached to their children’s –"like father, like son" or "like mother, like daughter" or something similar to that- because children will always imitate or mimic their parents before they can make their own decisions for every chance in their life. Unfortunately, if the parents ignore this issue in a long period of time, this will shut down the actual identity owned by their children.
           
              In "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory," issues regarding the identity formation seems to be dangerous because of unnatural attitude as greedy, spoiled, lack of respect, and temperamental contained within Augustus Loop, Veruca Salt, Violet Beauregarde, and Mike Teavee actually manifest as an identity that never protested or questioned by themselves so that they are each taking their given identity for granted while there is abnormal behavior that is already embedded in their “given identity”.
            To prevent it becomes prolonged, one of the actions that can be done is by removing/separating them from their identities that has been “contaminated”with abnormalities
“A person is either cut off from society or marginalized through isolation or prescribed some type of treatment to correct their “abnormal” behavior such as psychotherapy or medicine (not of the “marvelous kind”). (in “Dahl and Philosophy”, p. 113)
Through various accidents that cause these four children experienced some changes in their physical form which is permanent. Augustus Gloop who was very fat become as thin as a straw, Violet Beauregarde despite the size of her body back to normal but her face became purple, Veruca Salt and her family are simply covered with rubbish, and Mike Teavee who previously have a posture that is not too high turn into very high (about 10 feet) and he is also very thin (as thin as wire).
             
             The physical changes experienced by the four children at first glance do look a bit outrageous, but if but if we go back on the understanding that this is a fantastic novel, there is no problem with the physical changes that occur to the four children who are involved in this story.
“…the lacking is of the same nature as the existing; it would suffice to reverse the situation in order for it to become the existing to which the lacking is missing, while the existing would become the lacking.” (in “Being and Nothingness”, p. 86)           
Even so, they could break away from the "given identity" as greedy, spoiled, lack of respect, and temperamental beings and fix the “abnormal” behavior that previously existed in each of them.




Work Cited:
Dahl, Roald. (1990). Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. In THE COMPLETE ADVENTURES OF CHARLIE AND MR WILLY WONKA (pp. 11-160). Puffin Books

Dale, M. Timothy., & Joseph J. (2014). SHATTERING THE GLASS ELEVATOR: Authenticity and Social Order in the Works of Roald Dahl. In Held, M. Jacob (Ed.), ROALD DAHL AND PHILOSOPHY: A Little Nonsense Now And Then (pp. 107-119). United Kingdom: Rowman & Littlefield

Heidegger, Martin. (1962). Being and Time (John Maquarrie & Edward Robinson, Trans.). Oxford: Blackwell

Rider, Benjamin. (2014). EPICURUS AND THE CHOCOLATE FACTORY. In Held, M. Jacob (Ed.),  
ROALD DAHL AND PHILOSOPHY: A Little Nonsense Now And Then (pp. 7-18). United Kingdom: Rowman & Littlefield

Sartre, J. Paul. (1993). Being and Nothingness (Hazel E. Barnes, Trans.). Oxford: Blackwell

Todorov, Tzvetan. (1975). The Fantastic. New York: Cornell University Press


Selasa, 06 Januari 2015

Desire From Given Identity and Punishment To Forming Children’s Identity In Roald Dahl’s “Charlie and the Chocolate Factory” (1)



I want to address an unnatural desire among children in the novel Charlie and The Chocolate Factory because theywere so obsessed on one thing that seems to be always fulfilled such for  Augustus Gloop already consider food as a hobby and food is the only thing that can attract his attention (as if he should always eat, unlike those in General who only eat when hungry and stop when they are full); Violet who obsessed to break the record for chewing gum so that wherever she goes and whatever she does, he cannot be separated from the gum; Veruca, who always want various things (she doesn't care if it's a living thing or not), no matter how strange the desired object, no matter how hard to get that object, she should be able to get what she wants. She would cry and throw tantrums if she cannot get the object she desired; Mike Teavee that seemed to devote his life only to television would be very upset if he can't watch television or if there are people who are considered disturbing activities are watching television. Who considered as a distraction to his focus while watching television.
Unnatural desire or abnormal behavior shown on the children's attitude was not purely derived from each self, as following quotation from "Being and Time":
“In talking, Dasein expresses itself [spricht sich…aus] not because it has, in the first instance, been encapsulated as something ‘internal’ over against something outside, but because as being-in-the-world it is already ‘outside’ when it understands.” (p.205)
and Sartre in “Being and Nothingness”:
“Human reality is not something which exists first in order afterwards to lack this or that; it exists first as lack and in immediate, synthetic connection with what it lacks.” (p.89)
In the very ends, the various abnormal desires which are influenced by their given identity seems to perform counteroffensive against them and physically can be said this has been a totally deconstruct the identities that they get through the process of imitating and habituation to the various influences of their environment (in this case their parents) who eventually attached on the children. This not only alters the physical form but also automatically change the social life of children so as to form an identity that is completely new.

References
Dahl, Roald. (1990). Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. In THE COMPLETE ADVENTURES OF CHARLIE AND MR WILLY WONKA (pp. 11-160). Puffin Books
Sartre, J. Paul. (1993). Being and Nothingness (Hazel E. Barnes, Trans.). Oxford: Blackwell
Heidegger, Martin. (1962). Being and Time (John Maquarrie & Edward Robinson, Trans.). Oxford: Blackwell

Rabu, 12 November 2014

Magical Creature As Orality Threat Against Ontological Security Through Children's Desire





                Literary works have not only used as a medium of entertainment, but can also be used as a medium to convey ideologies or doctrines which are often implicitly inserted into the story she told so unconsciously, the reader will gradually follow the doctrine/understanding/ideas that are embedded in it. This is where the criticism is needed.
                According to Frye, “One obvious function of criticism is to mediate between the artist and his public” (in The Function Of Criticism At The Present Time, p. 34) the unique thing is, delivered a critique of a work or a policy, tradition, politics, etc. can be done via any medium through including novels such as 'Five Children And It' by Edith Nesbit.
               
With magical being named Psammead, sand-fairy that can grant any wishes that is spoken by people who find it though each of those wishes can only be granted until sunset. And there are also figures of five children humans who find Psammead near their house.
                Based on the brief description above, the novel Five Children And It is a fantasy genre novel (Magical Realism)
“Fantasy is a fiction evoking wonder and containing a substantial and irreducible element of the supernatural with which mortal characters in the story or the readers become at least partially familiar terms.” (Manlove, 1975, p. 1 in Exploring Children’s Literature – Teaching the Language and Reading the Fiction, p. 100)
because there are magically being and human beings whom interacts with each other in the story. In addition, from its setting, this novel can also be put into the category of 'low fantasy'
“In low fantasy, non-rational happenings occur in the rational world.” (in Exploring Children’s Literature – Teaching the Language and Reading the Fiction, p. 102)
In addition, any of the content of the story of this novel can be classified into fantasy for children that their wishes, which are always granted by the Psammead always brought problems that make children learned a valuable lesson. It is similar to Gamble and Yeats:
“A fantasy story in which magic is used to educate the children to think more carefully about what they wish for as wishes may well come true.” (in Exploring Children’s Literature – Teaching the Language and Reading the Fiction, p. 102)

Interestingly, Edith Nesbit interpreted evidence that the lesson or wisdom can only be obtained if we try not to be tied to the concept of good and bad which is taught through a variety of advice which used to stick to "they said...". If understanding in each chapter of this novel is matched with a concept that is already known to us on a daily basis, it seems to be quite difficult because here Nesbit precisely conveys her message by inverting understanding / existing doctrine.
This method is similar to the theory of deconstruction that is being stated in Miller's:
“Derrida, […] argues that we lead to think and express our thoughts in terms of opposites. […] these dichotomies, […] contain one term that our culture views as being superior and one term viewed as negative as inferior. Sometimes the superior or positive term seems only subtly positive […], whereas sometimes we know immediately which term is culturally preferable […]. But always the hierarchy exists.” (in Deconstruction, p. 200)
Among childhood, the understanding of good and bad or right and wrong come through imitate the adults or the advice they get from their parents. Even so, they (the children) just follow all doctrines, unconsciously, they are not becoming obedient because they want to be obedient but because they have to obey.

An understanding of good / bad and right / wrong that children primarily obtained from adults and the environment is their “comfort zone” because they know it is inherited from generation to generation so that it can assume that if it all obeyed, then their lives will be safe and peaceful Giddens refers to this as "ontological security" which is
“… a basic needs of individuals for a state of continuity and order in events, including those not directly within the perceptual environment of the individual. (in “State Personhood in Ontological Security Theories of International Relations and Chinese Nationalism: A Sceptical View”, p. 243 in Chinese Journal of International Politics Vol.2, p. 111)
In Five Children And It, the children are always faced with problems which aims to give them a real experience of the dichotomy of 'good-bad' as they bear the risk for any request that they ask on the only magical being character in this novel.

Psammead, magical figure being presented as the main axis of the story in this novel is a sand-fairy in charge of granting any request made by children (Robert, Anthea, Cyril, Jane, Lamb) who discovered it while their requests are often unreasonable and impossible to be realized within a short time by humans.
This figure seems to be the originator of the ontological security threatening causes for children because if this figure does not appear, then the kids will continue to follow the mindset of the 'good-bad' based on what they've heard from parents and the environment only. In short, they will be taking the ideas about good and bad for grantedness because they do not give it a try first. The understanding obtained in such a way that finally makes children misjudge their own environment.
Through Psammead, children earlier (excluding Lamb) alternately, asking for their wishes ranging from the reasonable wishes like wealth to unreasonable as having wings and growing up in a single day. Some of the chapters in this novel, even imply a somewhat political message and it seems a bit strange if delivered to children, such as a gendered issue to determine the power and powerlessness.

Since the days of the Prophet have been described and emphasized many times regarding the position between men and women were women always were below men. This doctrine eventually evolved in societies, passed on orally, and unwittingly, either adults or kids end up feeling comfortable with the existing gendered patterns and living trapped inside.
Nesbit interpreted the evidence in trying to criticize these things in different ways. Not with had called for feminist action, as what was done in Mohanty’s essay which eagerly declared that women should not stay silent
“But first she would have to speak, start speaking, stop saying that she has nothing to say! Stop learning in school that women are created to listen, to believe, to make no discoveries.” (in Under Western Eyes: Feminist Scholarship and Colonial Discourses, p.50)
He even criticized by insinuating men who supposedly have greater power to slowly follow the flow.
Although there are some parts that look underestimate / degrading to women as when the narrator says Anthea aspires to be 'a good servant' (p. 28); When the narrator says "You can always make girls believe things much easier than you can boys." (p. 30) as saying that women are easier to believe something, more innocent, and easier to and more easily manipulated than men; and decisions taken by Anthea on the appointment of Robert as spokesman when they want to buy a horse (p. 56).
But it's all just for the satirical notion that men have higher degrees/power than female if viewed the fact that Anthea, who find the Psammead and she is also the first finally decided on their 'contract' with Psammead. Women here act as a portal for all magic that happens, men do not contribute anything, they just pretend to have a role.
In addition, gender issues also arise when there is time they are dealing with a problem or confusion, one of them there are just referring to their father's advice by saying 'father say ...'. Although the children in this story experienced magical events, their parents were both absent, but the kids were just remembering what was said of her father, her mother is not at all involved.
Highly appears that the role of fathers has successfully shifted the role of the mother supposed to be the closest to the children But again, this is a satire that says “where is your father when the entire of his family need him?” When the mother came home, discovered the diamonds in her room, feeling the peculiarity that occurred while she was not at home, and then because she feel unsafe situations, nimbly without commanded by anyone she immediately secured her children at home and went to the police station without her husband (the last chapter).

In the Portals of Power explained that "the Nesbit's children's stories usually contain at least an underlying political concern." (in Portals of Power: Magical Agency and Transformation in Literary Fantasy, p. 71). This also applies to the novel Five Children And It when the four children were discussing servant’s habit after seeing Martha, the servant, would bring Lamb to meet her relatives.
“Servants never dream anything but the things in the Dream-book like snakes and oysters and going to a wedding-that means a funeral, and snakes are a false female friend, and oysters are babies.” –Anthea (p. 41)
“Servants do like taking babies to see their relations, […]; I’ve noticed it before-especially in their best things.” –Cyril (p. 42)
“Inspect they pretend they’re their own babies, and that they’re not servants at all, but married to noble dukes of high degree, and they say the babies are the little dukes and duchesses. –Jane (p. 42)
“She won’t enjoy herself most frightfully carrying our infant duke to Rochester, […] not if she’s anything like me-She won’t” –Robert (p. 42)
Thoughts which they say is the comments/responses are commonly made by adults to the servant who likes to invite children to their employers when they meet up with family or relatives.
The way children perceive about the servant seem to be opinions which stated dishonestly by themselves, they just re-stating what have been taught among their surrounding environment, as expressed by Manlove:
“We have to emphasize that hegemony is not singular; indeed that its own internal structures are highly complex, and have continually to be renewed, recreated and defended; and by the same token, that they can be continually challenged and in certain respect modified.” (in Base And Superstructure In Marxist Cultural Theory, p. 458)
Which is applied when the children were arrested on charges of committing theft because they brings a lot of gold pieces from Psammead, they met Martha, their servant, who ultimately defend the children so they do not arrest by the police.
 “If you’re quite done a-browbeating of the innocent children, […] I’ll hire a private carriage and we’ll drive home to their papa’s mansion. You’ll hear about this again young man - I told you they hadn’t got any gold, when you were pretending to see it in their poor helpless hands. It’s early in the day for a constable on duty not to be able to trust his own eyes. As to the other one, the less said the better; he keeps the Saracen’s Head, and he knows best what his liquor’s like.” (p. 61)
This makes the assumption about the servant that they get from the adults and their environment proved to be wrong. In fact, the maid is not as bad as the description given by adults and/or their environment.

                Issues regarding the stereotype that "inherited" from generation to generation as it happens to the class differences were also occurring amid race issue as it happened when Robert unintentionally ask for the third wish:
“Anybody would want him, indeed! Only they don’t; Martha doesn’t, not really, or she’d jolly well keep him with her. He’s a little nuisance, that’s what he is. It’s too bad. I only wish everybody did want him with all their hearts; we might get some peace in our lives.” (p. 71)
At the location where the Psammead usually appears as Martha as let Lamb while they themselves do not want to bring him wherever they go. Until this request dragging them into a big problem; Lamb was kidnapped by Lady Chittenden and ended up with four brothers struggle to escape from the Gipsy and bring him back home.
                But that appears here is precisely the Gipsy then constituted as the majority (master) and children (white) became minority (slave) which experienced pressure from the Gipsy as they would accuse of acting rude towards their group.
“Oh Yes! […] and then fetch the police with a pack of lies about it being your baby instead of ours! D’jever catch a weasel asleep?” (p. 82)
Even after sunset even the kids were still ignored by the Gipsy; treated as if their presence is not at all expected. Only Amelia, who still care about them even after the Psammead’s magic is gone, he still shows his attention to them
“Let me give him a kiss, miss– I don’t know what made us go for to behave so silly. Us gipsies don’t steal babies whatever they may tell you when you’re naughty. We’ve enough of our own, mostly. But I’ve lost all mine.” (p. 87)
And the gap between them seems to disappear after Lamb kissed Amelia (Gipsy woman) with dry lips, not wet as that of babies in general.
                Nesbit ways that reverse the situation between whites and colored it as if to affirm that racial difference is not important anymore. As in the following quote:
“In a society like ours, where most people take their race to be a significant aspect of their identity, it comes as a shock to many to learn that there is a fairly widespread concensus in the sciences of biology and anthropology that the word “race”, at least as it used in most unscientific discussions, refers to nothing that sciences should recognize as real.” (in Race, p. 277)

                Things threaten ontological security of these children also appeared in Five Children And It on page 90 that begins with their desire to write a letter to his mother, but eventually the plan is arguably failed because of things that sounds very silly. The four of them write letters but there is not one single letter that is managed well written.
                A letter written by Anthea exposed to spills ink and there’s no time to re-write or to fix it; Robert did not even know what to write, he finally just had to draw a ship in the paper; Cyril was already finished writing the letter, but somehow, the letter is lost when he was trying to trap slugs; Jane is the only one who almost succeeded but failed also because she takes a long time to think about the proper spelling for "Psammead" so it is not clear what she really wanted to said through the letter.
                Although these ideas don't come as one of their wishes to Psammead, but their ontological security would be threatened / annoyed by the absence of their letter which managed to convey their feelings and stories about the Psammead. The failure of these letters, implicitly states that children should not be voicing their arguments/opinions/problems/stories/guts to outsiders, as if they were silenced. Prohibited from written language, whereas orally, they know want they wanted to say.
                Instead of they are not able to write, they could have written all their guts, but it seems to be used to criticize the written culture and literate people, Nesbit switches the things around so that readers are aware that written language/literate culture is not everything because there's still an oral language as the former of written language.
According to the cases which I read in the Five Children And It (some I've mentioned and explain a little bit above), almost all requests on Psammead children will end up with a severe, mild, big and/or small problem. In addition, the Psammead’s position could relate gratitude as a trigger for an explosion that could cause problems, orality is also very involved to ontological security threat to children because all of their requests to Psammead only be granted if it was stated by using oral language.

                Five Children And It by Edith Nesbit was published in 1902 when the Victorian era had just ended and entered the Edwardian era (1901). Through this novel, Nesbit criticized the Edwardian era by creating a story that is contrary to the traditions/practices/policies/norms/regulations on Edwardian era as evident gap between the children of working-class group with a group of upper-class from what they can and cannot read, the game should and should not be done by girls and boys, regularity/subservience to older people, manners, until the location which usually used for upper class’ residences during the Edwardian era.

Through orality that can grant children, Psammead actually petrify children to be a robot, an automaton, without personal autonomy of action, an it without subjectivity as follows:
“The ‘magical’ act whereby one may attempt to turn someone else into stone, by ‘petrifying’ him; and, by extension, the act whereby one  negates the other person’s autonomy, ignores his feelings, regards him as a thing, kills the life in him.” (in The Divided Self: An Existential Study in Sanity and Madness, p. 46)
This is what is actually done by the Psammead. No matter what is being experienced by the children, they must make a wish every day. Initially this may be an opportunity that seems very nice, but after a long time, it makes the children become like a cyborg who routinely did that not because they really wanted to, but because it must be forced to.





References:
Appiah, K.A. (1990). “RACE” in Critical Terms for Literary Study,. ed. Lentricchia, Frank and McLaughlin, Thomas. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

 Arnold, Matthew. (2004).“The Function of Criticism in Our Present Time” in Critical Theory Since Plato, Wordsworth

 Campbell, Lori M. (2010). Portals of Power: Magical Agency and Transformation in Literary Fantasy. North Carolina: McFarland & Company, Inc., Publishers.

 Gamble, N. and Sally , Y. (2002). Exploring Children’s Literature – Teaching the Language and Reading the Fiction. London: Paul Chapman Publishing.

Krolikowski, A. (2008). “State Personhood in Ontological Security Theories of International Relations and Chinese Nationalism: A Sceptical View” in Chinese Journal of International Politics, Vol. 2, (pg. 109–133) downloaded from: http://cjip.oxfordjournals.org/

Laing, R. D. (1964). The Divided Self: An Existential Study in Sanity and Madness. London: Penguin Books.

Miller, J. Hillis.1989. “A Deconstructive Critic at Work” in Joseph Conrad, Heart of Darkness: A Case Study in Contemporary Criticism ed. Murfin, Ross C. (1989). New York: St. Martin’s Press  

Mohanty, Chandra .T. Under Western Eyes: Feminist Scholarship and Colonial Discourses. downloaded from:  jemym.no-ip.com/uwe.pdf

Nesbit, E. (1993). Five Children and It. Wordsworth Classics

Thompson, P. (1922). THE EDWARDIANS: The remaking of British society (2nd edition). London: Routledge.

Williams, Raymond.(1994). “Base and Superstructure” in Contemporary Literary Criticism ed. Con Davis, Robert and Schleifer, Ronald. New York and London: Longman Publishing Group.